Hallo CCCamp-Entitäten,
dem c3sustainability-Team "c3sus" ist unser Pool ins Auge gefallen. Auf der Mailingliste[0] wurde soeben eine Debatte über den Pool vom Zaun getreten und wie mir scheint, wird hier mit einer Menge Halbwissen betreffend dem exakten Stromverbrauch gedealt.
Interessierten Entitäten kann ich empfehlen, sich die Mailingliste mal näher anzuschauen. Ich habe im Archiv[1] der Mailingliste gesucht und scheinbar ist dies das erste mal, dass das Thema auf der Mailingliste besprochen wird. Also eine gute Gelegenheit für Pool-Orga-Entitäten sich einzumischen und den eigenen Standpunkt klar zu machen.
Disclaimer: ich war Nutzer vom Pool und fand die Idee & Umsetzung ziemlich cool. c3sus hat jedoch recht damit, dass der Energieverbrauch nicht gerade ökonomisch ist und das Projekt eine gewisse Dekadenz hatte. Ich sprach am 26.08. via Mastodon mit einer Entität vom c3sus über den Pool und behauptete, dass wir keinem den Kopf abreißen und man mit uns reden könne [citation needed]. Wollte ich hier mal geschrieben haben, bevor mein Name irgendwann mal ohne Kontext auftaucht.
<3 saxnot
[0]: https://hacc.uber.space/mailman/listinfo/c3sustainability [1]: https://hacc.uber.space/mailman/private/c3sustainability/
-------- Forwarded Message -------- Subject: [c3sus] Discussion about the high power drain pool heater on the Camp 2019 Date: Mon, 30 Sep 2019 19:50:26 +0200 From: chinatriesto@nuke.africa To: c3sustainability@hacc.uber.space
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event.
20kW (20000W)? No, it was 2000W (2kW).
Quote: "... if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Quote in german: " ... größere Verbraucher mitbringt (> 2 kW), meldet euch unbedingt bei Team Power und sprecht das ab (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Before that part there is written: English: It’s the same as for the water: please be thrifty and leave hungry consumers (e.g. old fridges or likewise) at home. german: Auch hier gilt: Seid sparsam und lasst überflüssige oder starke Verbraucher (Stichwort in die Jahre gekommene Kühlschränke oder ähnliche Kellerfunde) bitte direkt Zuhause.
Source: https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/wir-sind-in-der-natur-deal-with-it/ Backup: https://web.archive.org/web/20190709204025/https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/...
I was in the personal discussion next to the pool. The high power drain pool was NOT known to c3power team. When they have seen it, they told me and all other people standing around that they see this high power pool heater for the first time.
I wrote "against the camp-rules" like you have quote me right. The camp-rule was "if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de).". Have this been done? No. With other words - the camp-rules to report such devices was ignored - like i wrote that.
And for the people who dont know about that high energy heater. The story in short from my perspective:
I joined c3sus BECAUSE of this high power draining pool heater. This big pool had no protection about heat dissipation because it was build out of a plastic foil, EUR-pallet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EUR-pallet and some ropes holding the water together. Thats why you need really high power drain heaters running the whole time. They was running this heater 24/7. On saturday the pool was covered the whole day. This was also confirmed at a bigger discussion with c3power all standing next to this(many people to confirm that they told its was unused again the whole day). Up to this saturday this was for c3power a unknown high power drain device. The pool people who made the pool told to all critical people that was asking about the wasted energy that the diesel generators would need some basic load. When this was told to me i had in my mind "wtf? 20000W basic load? Times X generators??". C3power confirmed later that this was a lie from the pool people and there is no 20000W basic load required from the generators. Also there was more then enough load on the generators to be already out of the "basic load" - without the additional 20000W power drain for creating pool-heat. The 20000W power drain was told to me by the person who have build up this pool. I hope it was not even more power drain because the person already lied to the people about this "required minimum power drain from the generators". Yes, Fengel told me at the big discussion that the 20000W can be brought by the generators without any technical issues. But that was NEVER my point! I joined c3sus because of generating electricity with diesel by low efficiency, the diesel generators dissipate heat. This heat is completely unused and been blown out to the environment. Then 20000W of this low efficiency generated electricity is been taken and then been used to again create heat - that have not be used for the most of the day because the pool was covered by a foil. This triggered me so much, that i had to get active and do something against that.
And to be clear: There are ways to have much building-fun into creating a sustainable, warm pool for the camp. I am not for "no pool at all". I am for "never again a pool that gets heated by electricity that is been created by inefficient diesel generators. There was so much heat you could catch up by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_thermal_collector at the camp.
Maybe someone from c3power is reading here: If you make the rule, quote "you necessarily need to speak to our power team", and the people ignore you, why arent there ANY consequences when its ignored? Do you want that the people remember the c3power people like "it does not matter what they say"?
On 2019-09-28 21:39, Benjamin Lipp wrote:
On 28/09/2019 23:19, chinatriesto@nuke.africa wrote:
And dont forget that the 210000W cover things like the 24/7 running 20000W pool heater that was been put there on the camp - against the camp-rules.
I am jumping in on just this single point to make clear: the pool heater was /not/ running against camp rules.
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event. This is to allow c3power to do the planning and safety planning of the power network. If such a consumer is not announced beforehand, and it is found that it doesn't actually harm the safety of the power network, there is no need for c3power to stop this consumer. The pool heater was not harming the safety of the power network.
Please stop spreading that the pool was against the camp rules.
– Blipp
Bin ja auch für mehr Isolation am Pool. Der ist garnicht richtig warm geworden. Wenn man den abends wärmer bekommt und tagsüber ein bisschen Diesel einspart, fände ich das gut. Bisschen Glaswolle könnte schon was bringen. Wäre auch "cool" tagsüber einen kalten Pool zu haben. Aber kommt sicher drauf an, ob man den wieder aufgeheißt bekommt.
Auf dem HOA können wir ja theoretisch mit Ökostrom heißen.
Ansonsten stört mich die eine Person, die sich deswegen so engagiert glaube ich nicht weiter und ich würde die ruhen lassen. Das die Kostruktion absolut unsustainable ist hat deke ich nie jemand angezweifelt.
LG
On September 30, 2019 10:11:46 PM GMT+02:00, saxnot via Camp2019 camp2019@stratum0.org wrote:
Hallo CCCamp-Entitäten,
dem c3sustainability-Team "c3sus" ist unser Pool ins Auge gefallen. Auf der Mailingliste[0] wurde soeben eine Debatte über den Pool vom Zaun getreten und wie mir scheint, wird hier mit einer Menge Halbwissen betreffend dem exakten Stromverbrauch gedealt.
Interessierten Entitäten kann ich empfehlen, sich die Mailingliste mal näher anzuschauen. Ich habe im Archiv[1] der Mailingliste gesucht und scheinbar ist dies das erste mal, dass das Thema auf der Mailingliste besprochen wird. Also eine gute Gelegenheit für Pool-Orga-Entitäten sich einzumischen und den eigenen Standpunkt klar zu machen.
Disclaimer: ich war Nutzer vom Pool und fand die Idee & Umsetzung ziemlich cool. c3sus hat jedoch recht damit, dass der Energieverbrauch nicht gerade ökonomisch ist und das Projekt eine gewisse Dekadenz hatte. Ich sprach am 26.08. via Mastodon mit einer Entität vom c3sus über den Pool und behauptete, dass wir keinem den Kopf abreißen und man mit uns reden könne [citation needed]. Wollte ich hier mal geschrieben haben, bevor mein Name irgendwann mal ohne Kontext auftaucht.
<3 saxnot
-------- Forwarded Message -------- Subject: [c3sus] Discussion about the high power drain pool heater on the Camp 2019 Date: Mon, 30 Sep 2019 19:50:26 +0200 From: chinatriesto@nuke.africa To: c3sustainability@hacc.uber.space
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event.
20kW (20000W)? No, it was 2000W (2kW).
Quote: "... if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Quote in german: " ... größere Verbraucher mitbringt (> 2 kW), meldet euch unbedingt bei Team Power und sprecht das ab (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Before that part there is written: English: It’s the same as for the water: please be thrifty and leave hungry consumers (e.g. old fridges or likewise) at home. german: Auch hier gilt: Seid sparsam und lasst überflüssige oder starke Verbraucher (Stichwort in die Jahre gekommene Kühlschränke oder ähnliche Kellerfunde) bitte direkt Zuhause.
Source: https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/wir-sind-in-der-natur-deal-with-it/ Backup: https://web.archive.org/web/20190709204025/https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/...
I was in the personal discussion next to the pool. The high power drain pool was NOT known to c3power team. When they have seen it, they told me and all other people standing around that they see this high power pool heater for the first time.
I wrote "against the camp-rules" like you have quote me right. The camp-rule was "if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de).". Have this been done? No. With other words - the camp-rules to report such devices was ignored - like i wrote that.
And for the people who dont know about that high energy heater. The story in short from my perspective:
I joined c3sus BECAUSE of this high power draining pool heater. This big pool had no protection about heat dissipation because it was build out of a plastic foil, EUR-pallet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EUR-pallet and some ropes holding the water together. Thats why you need really high power drain heaters running the whole time. They was running this heater 24/7. On saturday the pool was covered the whole day. This was also confirmed at a bigger discussion with c3power all standing next to this(many people to confirm that they told its was unused again the whole day). Up to this saturday this was for c3power a unknown high power drain device. The pool people who made the pool told to all critical people that was asking about the wasted energy that the diesel generators would need some basic load. When this was told to me i had in my mind "wtf? 20000W basic load? Times X generators??". C3power confirmed later that this was a lie from the pool people and there is no 20000W basic load required from the generators. Also there was more then enough load on the generators to be already out of the "basic load" - without the additional 20000W power drain for creating pool-heat. The 20000W power drain was told to me by the person who have build up this pool. I hope it was not even more power drain because the person already lied to the people about this "required minimum power drain from the generators". Yes, Fengel told me at the big discussion that the 20000W can be brought by the generators without any technical issues. But that was NEVER my point! I joined c3sus because of generating electricity with diesel by low efficiency, the diesel generators dissipate heat. This heat is completely unused and been blown out to the environment. Then 20000W of this low efficiency generated electricity is been taken and then been used to again create heat - that have not be used for the most of the day because the pool was covered by a foil. This triggered me so much, that i had to get active and do something against that.
And to be clear: There are ways to have much building-fun into creating a sustainable, warm pool for the camp. I am not for "no pool at all". I am for "never again a pool that gets heated by electricity that is been created by inefficient diesel generators. There was so much heat you could catch up by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_thermal_collector at the camp.
Maybe someone from c3power is reading here: If you make the rule, quote "you necessarily need to speak to our power team", and the people ignore you, why arent there ANY consequences when its ignored? Do you want that the people remember the c3power people like "it does not matter what they say"?
On 2019-09-28 21:39, Benjamin Lipp wrote:
On 28/09/2019 23:19, chinatriesto@nuke.africa wrote:
And dont forget that the 210000W cover things like the 24/7 running 20000W pool heater that was been put there on the camp - against the camp-rules.
I am jumping in on just this single point to make clear: the pool heater was /not/ running against camp rules.
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event. This is to allow c3power to do the planning and safety planning of the power network. If such a consumer is not announced beforehand, and it is found that it doesn't actually harm the safety
of
the power network, there is no need for c3power to stop this
consumer.
The pool heater was not harming the safety of the power network.
Please stop spreading that the pool was against the camp rules.
– Blipp
-- c3sustainability mailing list c3sustainability@hacc.uber.space https://hacc.uber.space/mailman/listinfo/c3sustainability
Strom zu Hitze ist immer kacke - das weiß ja auch jeder hier. Könnt bestimmt den Vaillant Atmomag (20kw Gasdurchlauferhitzer) von mir benutzen, den nun Kenakapheus hat. Paar Gasbuddeln und fürs Gewissen noch CO2 Zertifikate und Solar :-)
Max!
On 30.09.19 22:49, Tim Schubert via Camp2019 wrote:
Bin ja auch für mehr Isolation am Pool. Der ist garnicht richtig warm geworden. Wenn man den abends wärmer bekommt und tagsüber ein bisschen Diesel einspart, fände ich das gut. Bisschen Glaswolle könnte schon was bringen. Wäre auch "cool" tagsüber einen kalten Pool zu haben. Aber kommt sicher drauf an, ob man den wieder aufgeheißt bekommt.
Auf dem HOA können wir ja theoretisch mit Ökostrom heißen.
Ansonsten stört mich die eine Person, die sich deswegen so engagiert glaube ich nicht weiter und ich würde die ruhen lassen. Das die Kostruktion absolut unsustainable ist hat deke ich nie jemand angezweifelt.
LG
On September 30, 2019 10:11:46 PM GMT+02:00, saxnot via Camp2019 camp2019@stratum0.org wrote:
Hallo CCCamp-Entitäten,
dem c3sustainability-Team "c3sus" ist unser Pool ins Auge gefallen. Auf der Mailingliste[0] wurde soeben eine Debatte über den Pool vom Zaun getreten und wie mir scheint, wird hier mit einer Menge Halbwissen betreffend dem exakten Stromverbrauch gedealt.
Interessierten Entitäten kann ich empfehlen, sich die Mailingliste mal näher anzuschauen. Ich habe im Archiv[1] der Mailingliste gesucht und scheinbar ist dies das erste mal, dass das Thema auf der Mailingliste besprochen wird. Also eine gute Gelegenheit für Pool-Orga-Entitäten sich einzumischen und den eigenen Standpunkt klar zu machen.
Disclaimer: ich war Nutzer vom Pool und fand die Idee & Umsetzung ziemlich cool. c3sus hat jedoch recht damit, dass der Energieverbrauch nicht gerade ökonomisch ist und das Projekt eine gewisse Dekadenz hatte. Ich sprach am 26.08. via Mastodon mit einer Entität vom c3sus über den Pool und behauptete, dass wir keinem den Kopf abreißen und man mit uns reden könne [citation needed]. Wollte ich hier mal geschrieben haben, bevor mein Name irgendwann mal ohne Kontext auftaucht.
<3 saxnot
-------- Forwarded Message -------- Subject: [c3sus] Discussion about the high power drain pool heater on the Camp 2019 Date: Mon, 30 Sep 2019 19:50:26 +0200 From: chinatriesto@nuke.africa To: c3sustainability@hacc.uber.space
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event.
20kW (20000W)? No, it was 2000W (2kW).
Quote: "... if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Quote in german: " ... größere Verbraucher mitbringt (> 2 kW), meldet euch unbedingt bei Team Power und sprecht das ab (camp2019@c3power.de). "
Before that part there is written: English: It’s the same as for the water: please be thrifty and leave hungry consumers (e.g. old fridges or likewise) at home. german: Auch hier gilt: Seid sparsam und lasst überflüssige oder starke Verbraucher (Stichwort in die Jahre gekommene Kühlschränke oder ähnliche Kellerfunde) bitte direkt Zuhause.
Source: https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/wir-sind-in-der-natur-deal-with-it/ Backup: https://web.archive.org/web/20190709204025/https://events.ccc.de/2019/05/24/...
I was in the personal discussion next to the pool. The high power drain pool was NOT known to c3power team. When they have seen it, they told me and all other people standing around that they see this high power pool heater for the first time.
I wrote "against the camp-rules" like you have quote me right. The camp-rule was "if you are bringing big power consumers (>2kW) you necessarily need to speak to our power team (camp2019@c3power.de).". Have this been done? No. With other words - the camp-rules to report such devices was ignored - like i wrote that.
And for the people who dont know about that high energy heater. The story in short from my perspective:
I joined c3sus BECAUSE of this high power draining pool heater. This big pool had no protection about heat dissipation because it was build out of a plastic foil, EUR-pallet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EUR-pallet and some ropes holding the water together. Thats why you need really high power drain heaters running the whole time. They was running this heater 24/7. On saturday the pool was covered the whole day. This was also confirmed at a bigger discussion with c3power all standing next to this(many people to confirm that they told its was unused again the whole day). Up to this saturday this was for c3power a unknown high power drain device. The pool people who made the pool told to all critical people that was asking about the wasted energy that the diesel generators would need some basic load. When this was told to me i had in my mind "wtf? 20000W basic load? Times X generators??". C3power confirmed later that this was a lie from the pool people and there is no 20000W basic load required from the generators. Also there was more then enough load on the generators to be already out of the "basic load" - without the additional 20000W power drain for creating pool-heat. The 20000W power drain was told to me by the person who have build up this pool. I hope it was not even more power drain because the person already lied to the people about this "required minimum power drain from the generators". Yes, Fengel told me at the big discussion that the 20000W can be brought by the generators without any technical issues. But that was NEVER my point! I joined c3sus because of generating electricity with diesel by low efficiency, the diesel generators dissipate heat. This heat is completely unused and been blown out to the environment. Then 20000W of this low efficiency generated electricity is been taken and then been used to again create heat - that have not be used for the most of the day because the pool was covered by a foil. This triggered me so much, that i had to get active and do something against that.
And to be clear: There are ways to have much building-fun into creating a sustainable, warm pool for the camp. I am not for "no pool at all". I am for "never again a pool that gets heated by electricity that is been created by inefficient diesel generators. There was so much heat you could catch up by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_thermal_collector at the camp.
Maybe someone from c3power is reading here: If you make the rule, quote "you necessarily need to speak to our power team", and the people ignore you, why arent there ANY consequences when its ignored? Do you want that the people remember the c3power people like "it does not matter what they say"?
On 2019-09-28 21:39, Benjamin Lipp wrote:
On 28/09/2019 23:19, chinatriesto@nuke.africa wrote:
And dont forget that the 210000W cover things like the 24/7 running 20000W pool heater that was been put there on the camp - against the camp-rules.
I am jumping in on just this single point to make clear: the pool heater was /not/ running against camp rules.
There is a rule that consumers >=20kW should be announced to c3power before the event. This is to allow c3power to do the planning and safety planning of the power network. If such a consumer is not announced beforehand, and it is found that it doesn't actually harm the safety
of
the power network, there is no need for c3power to stop this
consumer.
The pool heater was not harming the safety of the power network.
Please stop spreading that the pool was against the camp rules.
– Blipp
-- c3sustainability mailing list c3sustainability@hacc.uber.space https://hacc.uber.space/mailman/listinfo/c3sustainability
Camp2019 mailing list Camp2019@stratum0.org https://lists.stratum0.org/mailman/listinfo/camp2019